Maths Inquiry 2016
See here for a link to 2015 inquiry
- Team Kahikatea, middle team met with the maths advisors running professional development at St Mary’s in 2016 (the same ones retained from last year). It was a discussion of how we were going to run our inquiry/ies in 2016 and what were to be our main goals and areas of focus. New team leader Margot Neilsen is strong in maths and lead the discussion. We looked at the goals from last year that involved using more equipment, the problem solving approach to teaching group maths and stimulating increased maths discourse among students particularly through the use of the ‘talk moves’ by teachers to promote student talk:
See here for a link to 2015 inquiry
- Team Kahikatea, middle team met with the maths advisors running professional development at St Mary’s in 2016 (the same ones retained from last year). It was a discussion of how we were going to run our inquiry/ies in 2016 and what were to be our main goals and areas of focus. New team leader Margot Neilsen is strong in maths and lead the discussion. We looked at the goals from last year that involved using more equipment, the problem solving approach to teaching group maths and stimulating increased maths discourse among students particularly through the use of the ‘talk moves’ by teachers to promote student talk:
Talk Moves
Maths move talks support mathematical thinking, talk formats that provide different ways to organise students conversation and creates a classroom of respect and equal access to participation.
Develops mathematical thinkers
To support mathematical thinking and learning.
- Revoicing
- Restate
- Reasoning
- Add on
- Wait time
It was then decided that our focus was going to be on a team inquiry around using mixed ability grouping and the problem solving approach to group teaching. We would commence by taking most of the class or a group through a single problem and see the range of answers we get at the various stages - and see how much the children can talk about their maths thinking and the richness of the discourse.
17/3/16 - St Patrick's Day
Performed the initial task using the subtraction problem on the team site the team site - see picture below. Children were given the problem on an A4 sheet with access to a pencil, numberlines and whiteboard markers, beans, interlocking cubes and blocks. Initial observations showed:
Equipment: Aliyah - gets out beans (does a lot of playing with the beans and counts them out - later makes tally marks on her sheet and does the same thing. Patrick and Paul use connector blocks and start taking away from blocks. Mia counts on fingers initially and then seems to be sitting there thinking. Flossie works on paper only as does George.
I try to give the children lots of time to work out the problem individually and the early finishers to try and record in some way how they worked out their answer on the paper and to keep any materials they used in front of them to help them to explain their answers. A couple of children including Patrick seemed to take a considerable period of time to find an answer but ended up coming up with a good strategy involving splitting the 9 into 4 and 5 to subtract them separately. Others I think took a lot of time but didn't do much, covering up the use of a simple strategy - such as Mia.
Mia was the only child who worked it out by counting back - in 2s she said, which makes her stage 4, all the others except Flossie used the 4 and 5 split - which is stage 5i. Flossie took away 10 and added back on 1 - stage 5ii.
After the children were given time to solve the problem individually they each presented back to the group in some manner and I tried to get them talking as much as possible and get the talk moves going. Certainly I gave waiting time and gave the children time to talk and listened to them first. looking back at the video I feel that I still did alot of the talking, especially revoicing what other students had said to clarify but also because some of them talk quite softly, and it is even hard to pick up on the video audio. I also tried to get the children to give the reasoning for their own strategies, but found it hard to get reasoning or restating going at this stage for other children's answers. The children were not always focused on the whole group during feedback and some still think it is each child individually reporting back to the teacher, rather than a group mathematical discussion.
The children seemed to have no problem decoding the problem and all seemed comfortable using the problem solving technique.
The mixed ability grouping worked in the sense we got a full range of answers from stage 4 to 5i so that the children/child from that lower grouping was exposed to discussions of two other higher strategies that may begin to be used.
For next time - I would like to begin using the restating and reasoning talk moves to get the children in to the habit of commenting and listening to other children's contributions/strategies and solutions.
From the video observation I see that I need to relinquish control a little bit and let the children interact but I need to get those interactive talk moves going first.
Our team enquiry is mainly going to be focused on using these talk moves and materials in a mixed ability grouping scenario for mat teaching. I would like to see how the teaching will develop using the more interactive talk moves in this mixed ability grouping environment.
17/3/16 - St Patrick's Day
Performed the initial task using the subtraction problem on the team site the team site - see picture below. Children were given the problem on an A4 sheet with access to a pencil, numberlines and whiteboard markers, beans, interlocking cubes and blocks. Initial observations showed:
Equipment: Aliyah - gets out beans (does a lot of playing with the beans and counts them out - later makes tally marks on her sheet and does the same thing. Patrick and Paul use connector blocks and start taking away from blocks. Mia counts on fingers initially and then seems to be sitting there thinking. Flossie works on paper only as does George.
I try to give the children lots of time to work out the problem individually and the early finishers to try and record in some way how they worked out their answer on the paper and to keep any materials they used in front of them to help them to explain their answers. A couple of children including Patrick seemed to take a considerable period of time to find an answer but ended up coming up with a good strategy involving splitting the 9 into 4 and 5 to subtract them separately. Others I think took a lot of time but didn't do much, covering up the use of a simple strategy - such as Mia.
Mia was the only child who worked it out by counting back - in 2s she said, which makes her stage 4, all the others except Flossie used the 4 and 5 split - which is stage 5i. Flossie took away 10 and added back on 1 - stage 5ii.
After the children were given time to solve the problem individually they each presented back to the group in some manner and I tried to get them talking as much as possible and get the talk moves going. Certainly I gave waiting time and gave the children time to talk and listened to them first. looking back at the video I feel that I still did alot of the talking, especially revoicing what other students had said to clarify but also because some of them talk quite softly, and it is even hard to pick up on the video audio. I also tried to get the children to give the reasoning for their own strategies, but found it hard to get reasoning or restating going at this stage for other children's answers. The children were not always focused on the whole group during feedback and some still think it is each child individually reporting back to the teacher, rather than a group mathematical discussion.
The children seemed to have no problem decoding the problem and all seemed comfortable using the problem solving technique.
The mixed ability grouping worked in the sense we got a full range of answers from stage 4 to 5i so that the children/child from that lower grouping was exposed to discussions of two other higher strategies that may begin to be used.
For next time - I would like to begin using the restating and reasoning talk moves to get the children in to the habit of commenting and listening to other children's contributions/strategies and solutions.
From the video observation I see that I need to relinquish control a little bit and let the children interact but I need to get those interactive talk moves going first.
Our team enquiry is mainly going to be focused on using these talk moves and materials in a mixed ability grouping scenario for mat teaching. I would like to see how the teaching will develop using the more interactive talk moves in this mixed ability grouping environment.
Maths Measurement Rich Task given to children to show problem solving strategy work and self assessment.
Maths observation sheet from observation by team leader and professional development for maths leader - Honour - 23/6/16
I proceeded to undertake a mini inquiry myself as part of the team inquiry process into how to write a good problem.
Some findings are discussed at this link here as well as the findings of other middle school team members.
Our team inquiry for maths for 2016 in middle school can be found here
